US Travel Guide

NFL and former players reach deal to end race as factor to decide payouts in concussion settlement programme | US News

The NFL and legal professionals for hundreds of retired players have reached an settlement to end using a race-based methodology to consider dementia claims in the league’s landmark concussion settlement programme.

It follows public outrage over using “race-norming” – a follow that critics mentioned made it troublesome for black retired players to qualify for payouts, and which got here to gentle after former players Najeh Davenport and Kevin Henry filed a civil rights lawsuit over it final yr.

The methodology assumes black players begin with decrease cognitive operate than white players, which makes it tougher for them to present they undergo from a psychological impairment linked to their enjoying days.

Najeh Davenport
Former Pittsburgh Steelers star Najeh Davenport (pictured) and Kevin Henry filed a civil rights lawsuit over the follow. Pic: AP

Critics say it might have prevented tons of of black players affected by dementia to win awards that common $500,000 or extra.

The overwhelming majority of the league’s players – 70% of energetic players and greater than 60% of those that are presently retired – are black.


The revised testing plan means former black players will now have the prospect to have their checks reassessed, and in some instances, search a brand new spherical of cognitive testing, in accordance to the settlement.

Details of the deal filed on Wednesday in a federal courtroom had been first reported in The New York Times.

“No race norms or race demographic estimates – whether or not black or white – shall be used in the settlement programme going ahead,” the proposal mentioned.

It nonetheless wants to be accredited by a choose, however follows months of closed-door negotiations between the NFL and legal professionals for the retired players, plus these representing Davenport and Henry.


“We look ahead to the courtroom’s immediate approval of the settlement, which offers for a race-neutral analysis course of that can guarantee diagnostic accuracy and equity in the concussion settlement,” NFL lawyer Brad Karp mentioned in a press release.

Cyril Smith, a lawyer for Davenport and Henry, advised ABC information the settlement was “an enormous win” for black players, whereas Christopher Seeger, the counsel representing all former players and their households, hailed the deal as a “exhausting fought” victory.

The concussion fund has to date paid out $821m for a number of kinds of mind accidents, together with early and superior dementia, Parkinson’s illness and Lou Gehrig’s illness, additionally recognized as ALS.

The binary scoring system used in dementia testing was developed by neurologists in the Nineteen Nineties as a means to factor in a affected person’s socioeconomic background.


Lawyers representing the black players suspect white players had been qualifying for awards at two or thrice the speed of black players because the payouts started in 2017.

It’s unclear whether or not a racial breakdown of payouts will ever be carried out – or made public – however some players have requested the Civil Rights Division of the Justice Department to examine the matter.

Nearly 20,000 NFL retirees have registered for the settlement programme, which presents monitoring, testing and, for some, compensation.


Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button